Ask, Answer, Discover Knowledge
Login  |   Sign Up  |   Help

Discover > Answered Question

Reward
$42
Wrongful death action against defendants in different states
Asked by: goodfaithchapel from -
A disabled person who resides in Delaware filed a wrongful death and medical malpractice suit against a hospital in Maryland for the death of someone who was a beloved friend and companion to him. Since the plaintiff lives in DE and the hospital is located in MD, the plaintiff filed his suit in the U.S. District Court in MD on the basis of diversity of jurisdiction. The person who died at that hospital did not want to be there and wanted to go home; also, one of the hospital's cardiologists had her sign a document she could not read without her reading glasses, and was not told what it was she was signing. She was an elderly woman. The plaintiff also had medical power of attorney on behalf of the woman and showed them to the doctor, but the doctor would not respect that power of attorney. The document turned out to be an authorization for them to proceed with preventative heart surgery on her (even though she was in reasonably good health). The heart surgery they did actually caused to have a heart attack rather than prevent one. Though the central event that gave rise to the action - the death of that person- took place in MD, there were parties in DE that played a role that led to the death of that elderly woman at the hospital in MD.

The persons in DE are:
* the hospital in DE that authorized the release and transfer of that person from their care to the hospital in MD

* the doctor on the staff of that hospital in DE, who was not the woman's personal physician nor treating her, who ordered her transfer to the hospital in MD ( unbeknownst to her and against her will).

The question is: Can the plaintiff sue these persons that are in DE? If so, in what court? Should be sue them in a state court in DE, or should he add them to the federal suit he filed in MD, even though they reside in the same state as he does? How should he proceed without destroying the MD U.S. court's jurisdiction, and without excluding needed defendants? Are the DE people needed?
Share: Digg del.icio.us  facebook  StumbleUpon Toolbar Stumble It! reddit
 

All Answers

Showing 1-5 from 5 Answers
User Rating:
Compliment Answer:    
Answer Compliments:   0  
I am not an attorney and good for me for that. I have had some college law and numerous seminars on the general subject.

First, anybody can sue anybody. Whether they win or not depends legally on whether the medical standards of Maryland were followed. But other factors come into play.

...
Answer Date: 07:28am 07/07/08
 
User Rating:
Compliment Answer:    
Answer Compliments:   0  
there are lawyers who will gladly answer all your questions, for free. but I would find a l;awyer that would take this case on consignment. This sounds like a very open and shut case, but DO NOT waste any time. My answer is SEE A LAWYER IMMEDIATELY. or ANOTHER LAWYER. two lawyers are better than one.
Source: ex-plaintiff
Answer Date: 08:56am 07/07/08
 
User Rating:
Compliment Answer:    
Answer Compliments:   0  
I am not a lawyer, a professional immigration consultant, or a government official. Nothing in this document should be considered legal or professional advice in any jurisdiction. This is just for informational only.

Honesty, you should be seeking authentic legal advise from a Medical Malpractice Lawyer. If you haven't done so. By going to this person, all of your options would be explored what are best for you or others as an client. Th...
Answer Date: 03:50am 07/08/08
 
User Rating:
Compliment Answer:    
Answer Compliments:   0  
I am not yet a lawyer, but I had been investigating similar cases in the Philippines when I was still in the active police service. May we answer your questions one by one:

1. Can the plaintiff sue these persons that are in DE?

Firstly, the legal personality to sue on the part of the plaintiff must b...
Source: Civil Code; Revised Penal Code; and Criminal Procedure of the Philippines;
Answer Date: 08:31pm 07/09/08
 
User Rating:
Compliment Answer:    
Answer Compliments:   0  
The friend of the friend who died should sue. The hospital didnt mean to cause the person to die but the surgery did the exact opposite. They should sue for the medical costs of the surgery and transportation costs to and from the court; even if its just $30 for gas, it counts. Sorry for the loss of whoever died.
Answer Date: 03:43pm 07/12/08
 
About This User
Username goodfaithchapel
Questions 2 Total (0 Withdrawn)
Question Rewards $42.00 Total / 100% Awarded
Questions Rating
User selects Best Answer 50% of the time
About This Question
Answered Question
Question Reward GroupAsk Reward
$42.00 -
Posted 07/07/08 Closed 07/14/08
User Views 599 Answers 5
Location Other
URL
RSS
Related Questions